A grey Percheron draft horse standing by a wooden fence in a fall pasture

Friesian vs Percheron: Size, Temperament and Movement

Photo by Roger Starnes Sr on Unsplash

Friesian vs Percheron? Here’s the short of it. The Percheron is a draft horse, the bigger and heavier of the two, built to pull. The Friesian is a lighter riding and driving horse with high knee action, and its studbook takes only black.

Most Percherons stand 16-2 to 17-3 hands, and the average one weighs around 1,900 pounds. A typical Friesian stands 15.2 to 16 hands and weighs 1,300 pounds and up. Both are kind, willing horses. Picking a Friesian horse vs Percheron comes down to the job you’ve got waiting back at the barn.

Want dressage and a horse that turns heads at every show? Go Friesian. Want hay hauled, logs pulled out of the woods, or a big calm horse you can also ride? Go Percheron, and it isn’t close.

A grey Percheron draft horse standing by a wooden fence in a fall pasture
Photo by Roger Starnes Sr on Unsplash
Head to headFriesian vs Percheron at a glance
Friesian Percheron
Height 15.2 to 16 hands on average 15 to 19 hands, most 16-2 to 17-3
Weight 1,300 pounds and up on average About 1,900 pounds on average, up to 2,600
Color Black only in the studbook; a small star is the only white allowed Usually black or grey; sorrel and bay turn up in America, roan too
Hair Long, heavy mane and tail; heavy feathering at the fetlocks The British standard wants legs as clean and free of hair as possible
Temper­ament Gentle and clever, with a high-mettled streak Proud and willing; the standard calls for one that's easy to handle
Movement High knee action; in show harness, ideally a fast, high trot The standard calls for an easy, balanced gait; the British one adds a long, free stride
Main uses Riding, dressage, driving, light farm work Farm work, woodlot logging, carriage driving and riding
Homeland Friesland, in the Netherlands Le Perche, about 50 miles southwest of Paris
In North America Back since 1974; about 8,000 Dutch-studbook Friesians here Thousands imported in the 1880s; over 70% of purebred US draft horses in the 1930s census

A Friesian stallion has to reach 15.3 hands by age four to get into the adult studbook (mares need 15 hands). Percherons run anywhere from 15 hands clear up to 19, and all that size comes with a feed bill to match.

Size – Percherons Are Larger and Heavier

A pair of grey Percherons in harness pulling a driving cart past a fence
Photo by Jean Weber, INRA DIST, “Attelage Percheron Parcour Cl J weber0007 (24083519655)”, on Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

Percherons are the bigger breed. No contest. Most stand between 16-2 and 17-3 hands, though the breed runs anywhere from 15 to 19. The average one weighs around 1,900 pounds, and the real heavyweights hit 2,600.

Friesians average 15.2 to 16 hands and 1,300 pounds and up. Put a typical Percheron next to an average Friesian and it stands taller, carrying up to 600 more pounds.

The builds differ as much as the scale does. A good Percheron is close coupled and deep through the chest, with a big round hip and heavy muscle clear down into the lower thigh. A Friesian carries a small head on a high, upright neck. That’s where its proud, look-at-me outline comes from.

You’ll feel the size in the feed room, too. Most horses should eat about 2% of their body weight in hay a day. That’s roughly 26 pounds for a 1,300-pound Friesian and 38 pounds for a 1,900-pound Percheron, so 12 more pounds a day. Fed on hay alone all year, that’s a little over two tons more. Pasture changes the math, and so does grain for a horse in hard work. A good Percheron is expected to be an easy keeper, though, so yours may eat less. For a real number, plug your own horse into the horse feed calculator and the horse weight calculator.

See also  Horse Breeds Showdown: Friesian vs. Clydesdale – Unveiling the Differences

A big Percheron changes your shopping list, too. Think draft-sized halters and blankets and a roomy trailer. And a saddle that fits that wide back? That can be a long hunt all by itself.

Bigger riders eyeing either breed should also read our take on quarter horses for heavy riders. Then run your numbers through our rider weight calculator.

Temperament – Friesians Are a Touch More Spirited

Two black Friesian horses with long manes and feathered legs standing at a pasture fence
Photo by Daisyree Bakker, “Frysian horse”, on Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

A Friesian isn’t a hot-blooded horse. It’s counted among the warmbloods because of its temperament. A good Friesian is gentle and honest, yet high-mettled and clever, and that mix is a big part of its charm.

Percherons are proud and alert, and they’re willing workers. The breed is also expected to show marked tractability. That’s horseman talk for easy to handle and glad to do what you ask.

The British go even further. They hold up their own Percherons as among the most docile, good-natured horses of any breed, yet never dull or sluggish. Nothing much seems to rattle a good British one, whether it’s standing in a stall or out in town traffic.

The Friesian is bred to perform, and it has that high-mettled streak. British breeders credit their own Percherons with an almost total lack of nervous tension.

Every horse is its own animal, though. Look long enough and you’ll find a grumpy Percheron and a saint of a Friesian. So meet the horse, watch it handled, and ride it before any money changes hands.

If a Friesian sport horse is on your list, read our look at the Friesian and the Friesian sport horse before you shop.

Movement – Friesians Are Flashier

A black Friesian ridden at a horse show in Verona, lifting a front leg high in a showy step
Photo by Annalisa Parisi, “Friesian horse piaffe”, on Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Movement’s where the Friesian earns its fame. When Dutch inspectors judge a Friesian in hand, movement counts for 60% of the score and conformation 40%. That tells you what the breed’s built around.

That high knee action goes way back. Arabian blood came into the breed in the 16th and 17th centuries, much of it through Andalusian horses from Spain. It gave the Friesian those lofty knees and that small head on an upright neck.

In show harness, the ideal Friesian trots fast and high, powerful behind and roomy through the shoulder. Back in the 18th and 19th centuries, Friesians were in demand for the trotting races held in many Friesland towns. Those races ran a short stretch of about 325 meters.

The American Percheron standard calls for clean action and an easy, balanced gait. The British standard wants a straight, bold, long free stride rather than short, snappy steps.

Power doesn’t mean plodding, either. Before breeders made it heavier, its stagecoach ancestors had to trot 7 to 10 miles an hour, day in and day out. Greys and whites were preferred for that work because they showed up on the road at night. Purebreds have done well in heavy horse driving trials, too, and in the Route du Poisson, where distances of up to 17 km (about 10.5 miles) are covered at a trot.

Jumping isn’t either breed’s main line of work. Friesians were never bred as jumpers (some owners enjoy popping over fences anyway), and a few Percherons have turned into fine jumpers.

Coat Color – Studbook Friesians Are Always Black

A herd of black Friesian horses walking across a green pasture in Friesland
Photo by FaceMePLS, “Friese paarden – Elahuizen (48453411131)”, on Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

Every studbook-registered Friesian is black, from very dark brown or black-bay to true black. The only white allowed is a small star on the forehead. A Friesian can look black-bay while it’s shedding, or when sun or sweat bleach the coat, but it’s still a black horse underneath. Bays and greys did turn up in the breed long ago. Today black’s the only color recognized.

See also  Friesian vs Shire: Two Gentle Giants Side by Side

Percherons come mostly in black or grey. In America you’ll also find sorrels and bays, and roans show up as well. White on the face and feet is common, but too much of it gets frowned on. The British studbook’s stricter and takes only grey or black.

Grey runs deep in Percheron history. Pictures of medieval French knights almost always show a grey or white charger. In Britain, a Percheron’s color is expected to lighten with age, so a dark dapple may fade over the years.

Uses – Percherons Excel at Farm Work

A team of six draft horses pulling a cultivator across a field in Ohio
Photo by Randy Fath on Unsplash

Percherons were shaped by work. War horse first, then stagecoach horse, then city omnibus horse, and finally the heavy draft horse on farms and docks. They still pull heavy loads, and they’ve got enough style to pull a fine carriage.

In the woods they really shine. A Percheron can log a small woodlot without a wide road cut everywhere it goes. It keeps working in mud and snow where tractors bog down. These days plenty of folks work a team for the pleasure of it, too.

Friesians are riding and driving horses first. Folks use them for dressage and competition, for pleasure rides and drives, and even for light farm work. You’ll see them at shows in front of a high-wheeled gig, and pulling all sorts of carriages at Dutch ring-tilting events. But hitch one to a plow and expect Percheron results? I wouldn’t.

Maintenance – Friesians Require More Grooming

A small hand brushing a grey horse's coat with a wooden-backed brush
Photo by Chris Bair on Unsplash

A Friesian carries a whole lot of hair. There’s the long, heavy mane and tail, plus Shire-style feathering at the fetlocks. All of it needs brushing and checking, so plan on more grooming time than most breeds ask of you.

The Percheron can be the low-hair option. The British standard asks for legs as clean and free of hair as possible. In Britain that near lack of feather, along with the type of skin, is credited with much less risk of galls, itchy legs and poor coats, so even a less experienced owner can care for one.

Long leg hair can hide trouble. Chorioptic mange is the most common mange in horses, and it starts as itchy skin on the lower legs around the foot and fetlock. Draft horses get it often. If yours stamps or rubs one leg against the other, call your vet. Clipping the long hair helps the treatment along.

For brushes and combs, our horse grooming kit guide has you covered. And if a big mane is half the reason you want a Friesian (no judgment here), see which horse has the best hair.

Hooves and Legs – Check Under the Feather

A farrier pulling an old shoe off a dark horse's hoof
Photo by Lena Bauermeister on Unsplash

American breeders want clean action and quality feet and legs. The British standard adds hard blue horn on the hoof, and British owners see very little foot trouble, with legs that hold up well on hard roads.

With a Friesian, the feathering’s the thing to watch. All that hair hides the pastern and heel. So part it every time you pick out the feet, and look at the skin, not just the hoof.

Either way, keep your farrier on a regular schedule. Call your vet about any heat, swelling or crusting low on the leg. For more on shoes, read our post on why proper shoeing is vital.

See also  Andalusian vs Arabian Horse: History, Looks and Temperament

A big horse has big feet to hold up. Teach a young Percheron to stand politely for the farrier from day one, and your farrier’s back will thank you.

History – Both Breeds Go Back to War Horses

Two black Friesians in red-plumed harness pulling a carriage in a parade in Oudehorne, Friesland
Photo by Baykedevries, “Een span Friese paarden in de Optocht.Oudehorne”, on Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Both breeds go back to the age of the knight’s war horse. The Friesian comes from the old western European horse that reached its peak in the destrier, the knight’s mount. The Percheron’s earliest roots are shrouded in myth, but Le Perche was turning out heavy war horses long before the breed ever saw a plow.

When gunpowder ended the war horse’s days, Le Perche switched to stagecoach horses. Then came omnibus horses for Paris, and then the big farm and freight horse we know today. In the 1880s alone, almost 5,000 stallions and over 2,500 mares came over from France, most of them from Le Perche. In the 1930s census, more than 70% of America’s purebred draft horses were Percherons.

Then tractors nearly finished them off. American registrations fell to just 85 in 1954. Here, a small band of devoted owners kept the breed going, helped by thousands of Amish farmers who stuck with horse power. The Percheron came off The Livestock Conservancy’s priority list in 2013, with more than 32,000 worldwide.

The Friesian had its own close call. Its studbook opened in 1879, the oldest in the Netherlands, but crossbreeding nearly swallowed the old type. In 1913 a tiny group of Friesian lovers started a society that kept the breed alive. The breed first reached North America in the 1600s, vanished into crossbreeding, and came back in 1974. Today it’s mostly a riding horse and driving horse.

Training – Percherons and Friesians Learn Willingly

A black Friesian bowing on one knee under a sidesaddle rider in a long skirt in a sand arena
Photo by HVdep, “Frison révérence”, on Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Both breeds learn well. Friesians have a real talent for dressage, built on brains and a readiness to perform. Percherons are smart, willing workers, and the breed standard calls for one that’s easy to handle.

Where they differ is scale and spirit. Ride a high-mettled Friesian with soft, clear aids. Keep the sessions short and interesting, and a bright horse stays thinking with you instead of against you.

A Percheron’s calm is a gift in the early lessons. But 1,900 pounds of horse with sloppy ground manners is a real hazard, so teach it to lead, stand tied, pick up its feet and respect your space before you ask for anything fancy.

Either way, bring in a trainer who knows big horses for the first rides. Keep the lessons short and positive.

Driving’s its own skill, separate from riding. If you want a cart horse, find someone who starts horses in harness. Don’t guess at it out in the pasture.

Comparing Friesian and Percheron for Your Stable: Which One Fits?

A herd of grey Percheron horses grazing a pasture in front of tall fir trees
Photo by Jean Weber, INRA DIST, “Chevaux Percherons-1-cliche Jean Weber (24000902011)”, on Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

Pick the Friesian if you want dressage and the show ring, plus a black horse that stops traffic, and you don’t mind the grooming. Pick the Percheron if you want honest work and a steadier partner for a newer owner. Just make sure you can stack enough hay to feed one.

Thinking about a Friesian-Percheron cross? It could make a fine horse, but it’ll never carry main-book Friesian papers. Those go only to purebred Friesians bred under the Dutch studbook’s rules. The Friesian Horse Association of North America strongly discourages crossing studbook Friesians with other breeds, too.

Still weighing it? See how the Friesian stacks up in our Friesian vs Clydesdale, Friesian vs Shire and Friesian vs Andalusian comparisons. And once your new horse comes home, our list of unique horse names will help with the hardest call of all. Happy trails, y’all.

Sources


by